Anyone know what this might be?

Its really close to Better Times Alt Regular otf (400) font https://www.whatfontis.com/CR_Better-Times-Alt-Regular-otf-400.font?text=I%20trust%20in%20God

I can’t find this font. It gives an error and when I contacted the page admin (like it said to do) they said it’s no longer available? I just really like the way the “I” looks, but it looks a LOT different here than the original picture...